Our Nation’s Timberlands Flip: Mortality Exceeds Growth by 2:1
Because of climate change, our nations forests are dying faster than they are regenerating. This was not supposed to happen for a long, long tine. It’s really something that is not even projected, except in very vague terms about ecosystem transformation. But today, already, we see our forests dying faster than they can regenerate, regardless of the projections.
This reality tells us that the possibility of forest restoration in western North America is rapidly dwindling. The deeper meaning here is that climate change mitigation through forestation and reforestation is becoming challenged far beyond what we have been anticipating as one of the major mitigation methods to deflect the worst impacts of climate change.
The other highly disturbing thought about this news is that it means our forests are no longer absorbing greenhouse gases, but emitting them, further exacerbating warming. The numbers on this stark observation are not published in the academic literature yet, but when mortality exceeds growth, the carbon balance flips from one of sequestration to one of emissions.
The rate at which our national forests are dying foretells a scenario where recovery can only happen if we reduce warming. Reducing warming requires removal of long-lived climate pollutants from our skies. Emissions reductions, even the best-case scenario of the Paris Climate Change Commitments, do not reverse warming. Instead, they allow continued and dramatic warming which will only enhance forest dieback further. The numbers are staggering.
Even with Paris’ 80 percent emissions reductions by 2050 and 100 percent reduction by 2080, we can expect 2.1 to 2.6C warming by 2050 and 3.6C warming by 2100. This “best-case scenario,” because of the 30 year delay in enacting emissions reductions regulations, does not return warming to today’s levels for 135 years, and they do not return us to zero warming for well over 1,000 years. (see here)
Forest2Market was started in 2000 with a mission “to empower participants in the global forest, wood products, paper products, biochemical and bioenergy industries to make exponentially better decisions through the strategic application of industry expertise and unique datasets.” Their Market Watch post on May 18, 2018 summarizes Forest Resources of the United States, 2017: a technical document supporting the Forest Service 2020 Resource Planning Act (RPA) Assessment. The following quotes are from Forest2Market’s article:
“Per a 2017 Resources Planning Act (RPA) Assessment update to the Forest Resources of the United States technical document, the situation in public, government-managed forests in the western US is dire. Based on new data published in this RPA, the U.S. Forest Service (USFS) says that forest mortality exceeded net growth on America’s national forest timberlands in 2016.”
“Forest growth was 48 percent of mortality, while timber harvests were a mere 11 percent of what is dying annually—and this trend is on the rise. The agency estimates that 6.3 billion dead trees were standing in 11 Western states in 2015, up from 5.8 billion in 2010.”
They summarize western states standing dead timber in 2015:
- Montana: 1.2 billion, up 159 million since 2010
- Colorado: 834 million, up 153.2 million since 2010
- Idaho: 814 million, up 76 million since 2010
- Wyoming: 619 million, up 8.8 million since 2012
- Washington: 593 million, up 24.3 million since 2011
- Oregon: 571 million, down 7.7 million since 2010
- California: 499 million, up 29.5 million since 2010
- Utah: 436 million, up 30.9 million since 2010
- New Mexico: 341 million, up 20.4 million since 2013
- Arizona: 275 million, up 4.8 million since 2010
- Nevada: 145 million, up 1 million since 2012
Healthy Forests Healthy Communities put the data together like this: